Scotland 'should consider quarantining travellers from England'

Scotland should consider making travellers from England self-isolate for 14 days as the country is on track to be ‘Covid-free’ by the end of September, top scientist suggests

  • Professor Devi Sridhar has advised Nicola Sturgeon during the Covid-19 crisis 
  • She claimed that Scotland is on track to be ‘Covid-free’ by the end of September
  • Prof Sridhar argued the major challenge would be to prevent any imported cases
  • She said it would be ‘straightforward’ if Scotland was an island with no borders
  • And she added that ministers should ‘look across the world’, pointing to the US
  • Some states will make travellers from badly-hit states self-isolate for two weeks 

Scotland should consider quarantining travellers from England if the coronavirus crisis continues, one leading scientist has suggested.

Professor Devi Sridhar – who advises First Minister Nicola Sturgeon – claimed that Scotland is on track to be ‘Covid-free’ by the end of September. Scotland yesterday recorded no new Covid-19 deaths, marking three days in a row and the eighth time this month of zero fatalities.

But the outbreak has yet to fizzle out in England, with thousands of people still thought to be getting struck down with the virus every day. And England is still recording an average of 110 each day, despite Boris Johnson announcing a major relaxation of lockdown from this Saturday. 

Professor Sridhar, of Edinburgh University, admitted Scotland will see ‘little bumps’ moving forward, referring to future spikes in coronavirus cases. 

But she told the BBC the major challenge would be to prevent any imported cases of the disease, if the virus is no longer spreading naturally.

Professor Sridhar – part of the Scottish government’s Covid-19 advisory panel – said it would be ‘really straightforward’ to contain if Scotland was an island. But admitted ministers must find the ‘next best solution’ and pointed to moves made in parts of the US to make travellers from badly-hit states self-isolate for two weeks.

Professor Devi Sridhar thinks Scotland is on track to be ‘Covid-free’ by end of the summer

She pointed to New Zealand, which earlier this month declared victory over its Covid-19 outbreak after imposing one of the toughest lockdowns.

And she warned imported cases could set off ‘chains of infection’, which is exactly how the pandemic began after it spread from China. 

She added: ‘I think Scotland is on track to eliminate coronavirus by the end of the summer by looking at the rate of the decrease [in new cases].

‘But we are going to see little bumps, so it’s a question of how small can you keep those bumps.’

Professor Sridhar — who warned that the ‘risky’ and ‘ethically questionable’ strategy in England appears to be to let the virus keep spreading — suggested catching those cases ‘through screening, through quarantine, through testing’.

She added: ‘The next best thing is to look across the world at Australia, Germany and even the US.’

New York, New Jersey and Connecticut last week announced they will make visitors from states with high coronavirus rates self-isolate for two weeks.

The move – designed to stop another Covid-19 wave – will affect Americans travelling from states such as Florida, Texas and Alabama.

Currently, any overseas traveller entering Scotland – which shares its only land border with England – must self-isolate for 14 days or face a fine of up to £500.

People must also provide the Government with details of who they are, where they’ve been and where they’re going, within 48 hours of arriving in the country.

The measures only apply to people entering the country from outside the UK, Ireland, Channel Islands or the Isle of Man.

One Scottish government source told The Times that ministers were considering adding England into the list of affected countries.

But they told the newspaper that the restrictions may only apply to parts of England at the centre of growing outbreaks.

Some scientists have branded the quarantine measures as ‘completely useless’ and have called for it to be scrapped as soon as possible.

Other experts argued the move – which came into force in June and prompted warnings that it could kill off air travel completely – came too late.

A Scottish Government spokesman told The Telegraph: ‘To allow us to move out of lockdown it is critical that we keep transmission of the virus as low as possible – and that includes transmission from high to low risk areas.

‘We are, in common with countries across the world, having to take unprecedented steps to deal with the challenges that the Covid-19 pandemic brings.’

It comes after Ms Sturgeon last week predicted that Scotland was ‘not far away’ from eliminating the coronavirus.

But she warned the virus – scientifically known as SARS-CoV-2 – has ‘not yet gone away’ despite the ‘exceptional progress’ made.

Official figures show 450 Covid-19 patients are currently in hospital north of the border, including five who are fighting for their lives in intensive care.

In developments south of the border, it was today revealed that Leicester may be forced to extend the lockdown for a fortnight from Saturday.

The city’s mayor said health chiefs have suggested they will ask him to postpone opening pubs, museums and playgrounds on July 4/

Sir Peter Soulsby, who was previously a Labour MP for Leicester South, said: ‘What they’re suggesting is not a return to lockdown.

‘It seems that what they’re suggesting is that we continue the present level of restriction for a further two weeks beyond July 4.

‘Now that’s obviously very different from the dramatic lockdown in Leicester that was being briefed at the weekend.’ 

Source: Read Full Article